[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
VOTE SUMMARY: Voting Summary by Cluster

To: cve-editorial-board-list@lists.mitre.org
Subject: VOTE SUMMARY: Voting Summary by Cluster
From: "Steven M. Christey" <coley@linus.mitre.org>
Date: Mon, 9 Aug 1999 19:53:24 -0400 (EDT)
Sender: owner-cve-editorial-board-list@lists.mitre.org
Below is a breakdown of voting summaries by cluster.

Most of the recent clusters have had few voters.  This makes sense
since we've talked about high-level issues that significantly affect
those clusters.

The VERIFY-BUGTRAQ cluster has had no voters.  IDS, VERIFY-TOOL,
NETCONF, CDEC, RESTLOW, CGI, and MULT have only had one voter each.
They were proposed between June 23 and July 27.

Two-voter clusters include MPAN, SA-OTHER, SA-LITTLE, SA-ATTACK,
SA-HIST, NT-REGISTRY, DATA, CFMISC, NOVULN, PRIVACY, DESC, and
VERIFY-TOOL.

For the most part, the remaining clusters contain enough votes, but
most candidates are affected by unresolved content decisions.

- Steve



================ CERT ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(10)
  Shostack ACCEPT(14) MODIFY(2) NOOP(1) REJECT(1) REVIEWING(1)
  Frech ACCEPT(10) MODIFY(6) RECAST(1) REVIEWING(2)
  Hill ACCEPT(10)
  Christey MODIFY(2) RECAST(1) REVIEWING(3)
  Landfield ACCEPT(9)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(13) MODIFY(3) NOOP(1) RECAST(1) REVIEWING(1)


<FINAL> --> 41
<MODIFIED> --> 9
<PROPOSED> --> 10
ACCEPT --> 4
MODIFY --> 5
RECAST --> 3
REJECT --> 1
REVIEWING --> 6


================ VEN-AIX ===================
Voters:
  Frech MODIFY(4)
  Shostack ACCEPT(4)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(4)
  Prosser MODIFY(4)


<FINAL> --> 6
<INTERIM> --> 2
<PROPOSED> --> 2
MODIFY --> 4


================ VEN-SUN ===================
Voters:
  Frech ACCEPT(2) MODIFY(5)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(6) MODIFY(1)
  Prosser ACCEPT(3) MODIFY(4)


<FINAL> --> 11
<PROPOSED> --> 7
MODIFY --> 7


================ VEN-HP ===================
Voters:
  Frech ACCEPT(2)
  Shostack MODIFY(1) REVIEWING(1)
  Hill ACCEPT(2)
  Northcutt NOOP(2)


<FINAL> --> 9
<PROPOSED> --> 2
MODIFY --> 1
REVIEWING --> 1


================ VEN-SGI ===================
Voters:
  Frech MODIFY(1)
  Shostack MODIFY(1)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(1)


<FINAL> --> 6
<PROPOSED> --> 1
MODIFY --> 1


================ VEN-others ===================
Voters:
  Frech MODIFY(1)
  Shostack ACCEPT(1)
  Hill ACCEPT(1)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(1)
  Prosser MODIFY(1)


<FINAL> --> 1
<PROPOSED> --> 1
MODIFY --> 1


================ VEN-BSD ===================
Voters:
  Shostack MODIFY(4)
  Frech ACCEPT(1) MODIFY(11) REVIEWING(1)
  Hill ACCEPT(3) NOOP(1)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(3) MODIFY(1)


<FINAL> --> 9
<PROPOSED> --> 4
ACCEPT --> 1
MODIFY --> 11
REVIEWING --> 1


================ MULT ===================
Voters:
  Frech ACCEPT(11) MODIFY(19) RECAST(2) REVIEWING(2)


<PROPOSED> --> 34
ACCEPT --> 11
MODIFY --> 19
RECAST --> 2
REVIEWING --> 2


================ CGI ===================
Voters:
  Northcutt ACCEPT(31)


<PROPOSED> --> 31
ACCEPT --> 31


================ BUF ===================
Voters:
  Hill ACCEPT(32)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(32)


<MODIFIED> --> 1
<PROPOSED> --> 31
ACCEPT --> 32


================ NTLOW ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(14) MODIFY(2) NOOP(3)
  Hill ACCEPT(19)


<PROPOSED> --> 19
ACCEPT --> 17
MODIFY --> 2


================ DENY ===================
Voters:
  Hill ACCEPT(13)
  Meunier ACCEPT(8) MODIFY(2) NOOP(2) RECAST(1)


<PROPOSED> --> 13
ACCEPT --> 10
MODIFY --> 2
RECAST --> 1


================ RESTLOW ===================
Voters:
  Hill ACCEPT(39)


<PROPOSED> --> 39
ACCEPT --> 39


================ ONEREF ===================
Voters:
  Shostack ACCEPT(27) MODIFY(3) NOOP(12) RECAST(1)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(43)
  Prosser ACCEPT(3) MODIFY(22) NOOP(16) RECAST(1) REVIEWING(1)


<PROPOSED> --> 43
ACCEPT --> 18
MODIFY --> 22
RECAST --> 2
REVIEWING --> 1


================ NOREFS ===================
Voters:
  Wall MODIFY(4) NOOP(19)
  Shostack ACCEPT(8) MODIFY(6) NOOP(9)
  Northcutt NOOP(23)


<PROPOSED> --> 23
ACCEPT --> 5
MODIFY --> 10
NOOP --> 8


================ MULT2 ===================
Voters:
  Shostack ACCEPT(7) MODIFY(2) NOOP(3) REJECT(2)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(14)


<PROPOSED> --> 14
ACCEPT --> 10
MODIFY --> 2
REJECT --> 2


================ PASS ===================
Voters:
  Shostack ACCEPT(14)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(14)
  Baker ACCEPT(14)
  Meunier ACCEPT(14)


<PROPOSED> --> 14
ACCEPT --> 14


================ NTCONFIG ===================
Voters:
  Shostack ACCEPT(12) REJECT(1)
  Wall ACCEPT(12) REVIEWING(1)
  Ozancin ACCEPT(9) MODIFY(3) RECAST(1)
  Christey ACCEPT(2)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(2) MODIFY(1) NOOP(1) RECAST(3) REJECT(6)
  Baker ACCEPT(8) MODIFY(2) REJECT(1) REVIEWING(2)


<PROPOSED> --> 13
ACCEPT --> 3
MODIFY --> 1
RECAST --> 3
REJECT --> 6


================ DESIGN ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(13) NOOP(14)
  Ozancin ACCEPT(25) RECAST(2)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(13) NOOP(3) RECAST(1) REJECT(10)
  Baker ACCEPT(26) MODIFY(1)


<PROPOSED> --> 27
ACCEPT --> 13
MODIFY --> 1
RECAST --> 3
REJECT --> 10


================ MORELOW ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(14) MODIFY(2) NOOP(15) REJECT(1) REVIEWING(5)
  Ozancin ACCEPT(34) MODIFY(1) NOOP(2)
  Christey ACCEPT(1)


<PROPOSED> --> 37
ACCEPT --> 28
MODIFY --> 3
REJECT --> 1
REVIEWING --> 5


================ CDEC ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(8) MODIFY(2) NOOP(5)


<PROPOSED> --> 15
ACCEPT --> 8
MODIFY --> 2
NOOP --> 5


================ NETCONF ===================
Voters:
  Northcutt ACCEPT(3) NOOP(1) RECAST(1) REJECT(7)


<PROPOSED> --> 12
ACCEPT --> 3
NOOP --> 1
RECAST --> 1
REJECT --> 7


================ FINGER ===================
Voters:
  Shostack ACCEPT(1) MODIFY(5)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(2) NOOP(1) REJECT(3)


<PROPOSED> --> 6
ACCEPT --> 1
MODIFY --> 2
REJECT --> 3


================ IDS ===================
Voters:
  Northcutt ACCEPT(5)


<PROPOSED> --> 5
ACCEPT --> 5


================ VERIFY-BUGTRAQ ===================
Voters:


<PROPOSED> --> 23


================ VERIFY-TOOL ===================
Voters:
  FRECH NOOP(1)
  Shostack MODIFY(1)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(5) NOOP(2)


<PROPOSED> --> 7
ACCEPT --> 4
MODIFY --> 1
NOOP --> 2


================ DESC ===================
Voters:
  Wall MODIFY(1) NOOP(1)
  Northcutt NOOP(2)


<PROPOSED> --> 2
MODIFY --> 1
NOOP --> 1


================ PRIVACY ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(2) NOOP(7)
  Northcutt NOOP(9)


<PROPOSED> --> 9
ACCEPT --> 2
NOOP --> 7


================ NOVULN ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(5) NOOP(5) REJECT(9)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(6) NOOP(6) REJECT(7)


<PROPOSED> --> 19
ACCEPT --> 3
NOOP --> 3
REJECT --> 13


================ CFMISC ===================
Voters:
  Shostack ACCEPT(5) RECAST(6) REJECT(6)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(6) NOOP(3) REJECT(8)


<PROPOSED> --> 17
ACCEPT --> 3
RECAST --> 4
REJECT --> 10


================ DATA ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(10)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(3) RECAST(6) REJECT(1)


<PROPOSED> --> 10
ACCEPT --> 3
RECAST --> 6
REJECT --> 1


================ NT-REGISTRY ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(6)
  Northcutt RECAST(6)


<PROPOSED> --> 6
RECAST --> 6


================ SA-HIST ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(12) NOOP(1)
  Northcutt REJECT(13)


<PROPOSED> --> 13
REJECT --> 13


================ SA-ATTACK ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(9) REJECT(1)
  Northcutt REJECT(10)


<PROPOSED> --> 10
REJECT --> 10


================ SA-LITTLE ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(3) NOOP(2)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(1) REJECT(4)


<PROPOSED> --> 5
ACCEPT --> 1
REJECT --> 4


================ SA-OTHER ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(5) NOOP(3)
  Northcutt REJECT(8)


<PROPOSED> --> 8
REJECT --> 8


================ MPAN ===================
Voters:
  Wall ACCEPT(4)
  Northcutt ACCEPT(3) RECAST(1)


<PROPOSED> --> 4
ACCEPT --> 3
RECAST --> 1
Prev by Date: VOTE SUMMARY: Summary of all active candidates
Next by Date: VOTES: Recorded votes for recent clusters
Prev by thread: VOTE SUMMARY: Summary of all active candidates
Next by thread: VOTES: Recorded votes for recent clusters
Index(es):
- Date
- Thread