Re: CVE Entry Quality Working Group

• To: "Coffin, Chris" <ccoffin@mitre.org>, CVE Editorial Board Discussion <cve-editorial-board-list@mitre.org>
• Subject: Re: CVE Entry Quality Working Group
• From: Art Manion <amanion@cert.org>
• Date: Wed, 28 Nov 2018 15:20:33 -0500
• Authentication-results: spf=neutral (sender IP is 192.52.194.235) smtp.mailfrom=cert.org; imc.mitre.org; dkim=fail (body hash did not verify) header.d=cert.org;imc.mitre.org; dmarc=fail action=none header.from=cert.org;
• Autocrypt: addr=amanion@cert.org; keydata= xsFNBFoV8GMBEACXd7zH23Gx/W77Gr3Hs+n+BTtEt7IP0jU26vM9i4ASGewrIFZaRIOgL964 xX7Qk1wvxLl8HvUomLNHsJIZYG4EKcNkEfREO7lTx/3nYhG3wjF0DcHYuLwUkwAS3N6p9PQ7 bvEsXZMbfG0L8ASgRy0h4dWg+XGV4xT64REsIlzSsclVaHKTvP7FAMCDG70L/2wc+w24RAzs TYhfxLp4w8TBaVj/pONm+EDGVtK5u4LPLpLS0xmlGxgKP9mYSYAF3j44msAsbsuFPfWTa8JU s9yASol4pMECH24Cp3snHlSNHMl1APfVz3Xsfw5x/mekgCAPcGCARhA9ltRHLYgVMr1JCYZW JdyUB0UEiY0xvlb5JYfCFJm4fL8E2xoW/ATmDIxkU0qguL55AD2VYEwbWEsiP725YMSKBDaC cGH9fa2iuSxnflui6wR4K+FOjXfB2nF561q+HjlRb6bahdkYzWccX4fx3dSlZ6w62qRFNKAE 5zUfe2ZHwis9Bx9iqIp7Ini/sZ3ESJgMr7qlSSkYl10Esdl5CyFyxQ5g/LgzOlywdHazju13 /ckVBPo5vz9ZPOmafiUDSz6R/kbC0+nCrJSjIBvDfBWG7Gl2gon4HqB4Ji6r3+gFEFFJl+O/ PwID6Wh0jAjTQWvD+5L/vFTZ3/875Q2OcoxL9Hh4ls5ptg+7uwARAQABzR1BcnQgTWFuaW9u IDxhbWFuaW9uQGNlcnQub3JnPsLBkQQTAQgAOwIbAwIeAQIXgAULCQgHAwUVCgkICwUWAgMB ABYhBBHNrv2hhwlGumhcAVNt4uTRu2rfBQJaFmXUAhkBAAoJEFNt4uTRu2rfY1IP/j8cjh38 B0mnEo0Lk27r/mYRQhj2Yk/ClsAuPWea56BGAswtW2Q6g6DswcinjvTxrycSqAfpj2ZQP9Rx Ib/FsfozF5bC7Ja5/W4amH1NcTr/cE+sgKX3XZcRlOIrw2d0jmS1SAtDWPWn4zTYKoR7cbDz BAAABLb8/xQn7YFgf8nKQ4ZM0yOTUOnF7wG42UU0Y0ww3b+x2/ZMys0ntpz4ZSOgVJlun2xP WgFzkHu/fEJkVTPkZQweRULIGeFJBzuJP46+FMy6PJFZ/ZudzLy/VBMVAxA/yOszLbRvsl6z 3prRMgI+fJF/11ohRVQ5DWzS4AmfnI9RP6aOlUgEi4MYMcbYKrYGwguhGOpdg5iaO6ir4mhd OMcKLeV0ZqSef0ZpXTLQiTzWuFg9ECof5OCK/Y2VQ2EXyWIi7q4OPTFFoZBl2keoF6j0k272 PCYfJZIzq/ER9mfoH1+7nmIxvZ+XXQ6EoCCPv6le8VKQyZOFVgjD5rPvCeGZgAs9CRbfqYNm bF3jqeMk4kZbJ/+GsKv66M4R0VI2DijOLNF1kGXeU6s45lUBZmcT0Fb2MQ78rNItpeUP+XYj fpB0g/woOIstbSoOqpVZf++HIjnmMHj9jJrbFcMVIPac89EDcjbab3zPTMb5LHdk6AxMsWRM QqxofqoqqzNI7RiKisaDQhINXRwAzsBNBFoV8roBCADZKC4LLl6XhVvHCZZIwa9t2e+swdln YRtxwG1TDRxM1PaV7VDzB9K1FMRDC9CQQmiwI+Vl2j0Kn3BUvkCp3zmP+S7CRgK2vfP1GBAs CURE6j6M7S47qOhQvAvJK0qlF14tCBSX16CceGFV0XzfOUnQGt6m8AnVTr7WODilYsJPWUrj xLe3cKQJs7zk3iMLH1lJ7jNXlAQUgrTurVD7sl6PbKgbmDw3tIgXwep7tMOUzpiN4vCPALA+ WYL+0VxE03TZj/FqNzNrjoKXw+X3za675QnLsXww2cgLBV0Zjg3HZVDT5/0LlQjYqPnaWh3s ZG8uRJ104Thx1JVFLN4+8aDrABEBAAHCwXwEGAEIACYWIQQRza79oYcJRrpoXAFTbeLk0btq 3wUCWhXyugIbDAUJBaOagAAKCRBTbeLk0btq3zHYD/4vvS0lul3UKWGeRsVb33Y3eJ1yv4O3 EpBtmkVgCyxdG3zj8YrI15DCzhn6LSN3FqjV+wovE3SsxIrRjn7eoBA6SH54KlFRrW7pAARc NQaHFU+nX6ST6X3pOoNYzhXPZjkxoUpxyC+ehNARx+3tlQ0LScEr0L5Ttvr8W7nopWaXeuCt VI+8tjDnsCtWLaI2bYi3TYWDJdgWzNFSGYioqIxvQHIpokFZAx6fTKtEYaAqqg2cefRDgNoU bMcHmNtVMAXThLdNAx23F/sv2gV9a612ktCwl6hjKu1vuK4KGnhQu1T/oRk5EUA8jy5yBB6/ S5jwYbZR01EriZXSTXwT/gJcThBIXH8i9/4lUwdhV8+iBP/Pomhs8D7dPU7q1fUYlvVxn8iN K7IFoWdptGv+bhdNsf/qWGxVxOHwTAipr73Fl3eC5RovVM2aAK2Bx6xQFXlh4uPcI/S0gIPG tytClYZxtbXKM3qVhUTZgg1Ge6MgtgJkKWttzRciW0N9t5pZ/IbH7ax0NUv2hjHovGBXhuQb cVAEgmx90iyx9iRizCpgr3JyDNtKX+bc26aGI+mFOdiawp2HihhSazqiEpuNrxlQVWgMgmXa RduAg8L9z2CshZ6Zkcmwea79r8yDsBbwfJEZ71T0WWyfm1UcRVflPFAYb9xE8Ulgh8BQzw// z7Y5Lw==
• Delivery-date: Wed Nov 28 15:26:41 2018
• Dkim-filter: OpenDKIM Filter v2.11.0 veto.sei.cmu.edu wASKKX9g039724
• Dkim-signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=cert.org; s=yc2bmwvrj62m; t=1543436434; bh=dCjZoASB1HwrNTe717qaRSgBxq7hb/L7IWQcCwq5G7E=; h=Subject:To:References:From:Date:In-Reply-To:From; b=g6sssG6aHs8KQHdw3xqqC2rimNLhvWbnBiLqTeefRsiy3EXf8iIB0ow81POZ2W0Yp nHcaR3e1yHjs8bSzR7E0ntIhSLAlncIt5cZSq4wTk2baERksUHQiAKcNOZwKQ/f2OZ 23wUoB4ABJRPthhAFGPD6R4WhFKFQs5y8+1fyIOk=
• In-reply-to: <BN7PR09MB280317250ACC15083F88CBB6A1D70@BN7PR09MB2803.namprd09.prod.outlook.com>
• Openpgp: preference=signencrypt
• References: <BN7PR09MB280317250ACC15083F88CBB6A1D70@BN7PR09MB2803.namprd09.prod.outlook.com>
• Spamdiagnosticmetadata: NSPM
• Spamdiagnosticoutput: 1:99
• User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10.13; rv:60.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/60.3.1

On 11/26/18 9:32 AM, Coffin, Chris wrote:

The CVE team would like to judge your level of interest in establishing a 
CVE Entry Quality Working Group. The main focus of the group would be 
on improving the quality of CVE entry content. The output of the group would 
be best practices and guidelines on how to generate a CVE entry, and 
possibly propose changes to the CNA Rules.

+me please.

 - Art

• Follow-Ups:
  • RE: CVE Entry Quality Working Group
    • From: <uchiyama.taki@jp.panasonic.com>

• References:
  • CVE Entry Quality Working Group
    • From: "Coffin, Chris" <ccoffin@mitre.org>

• Prev by Date: CVE Board Meeting Agenda - November 28, 2018
• Next by Date: Kathleen Trimble (DHS) Voted in as CVE Board Member
• Previous by thread: Re: CVE Entry Quality Working Group
• Next by thread: RE: CVE Entry Quality Working Group
• Index(es):
  • Date
  • Thread